Deep plane or SMAS plication: at a glance
- Deep planeSMAS lifted, ligaments released
- PlicationSMAS folded, ligaments preserved
- Duration2 to 4 hours
- Time off15 to 21 days
- Result4 to 12 years
- Cost€5,000 to €15,000
Every modern facelift works on the SMAS, the musculo-aponeurotic layer that lies beneath the fat of the face. There are two families of technique. In the first, the SMAS is lifted as a flap and the retaining ligaments that anchor the cheek and jaw are released: this is the SMAS flap, once called the “SMAS lift” and now the “deep plane facelift”. The tissues are then repositioned as one unit, with no pull on the skin. In the second, the SMAS is folded onto itself with stitches (plication), without being lifted, and the ligaments stay in place: the procedure is simpler, but it does less for the cheek and the nasolabial fold. Studies show high satisfaction with both families and no difference in permanent facial nerve injury. A skin-only facelift, with nothing done to the SMAS, should no longer be performed: the result is weak, often unnatural, and the scars tend to widen.
Cost of a lower face and neck lift: €5,000 to €15,000, on quotation after a consultation (€100).
1. The layers of the face and the retaining ligaments
The face is made of layers stacked on top of one another, from the surface down:
- the skin;
- the subcutaneous fat;
- the SMAS (superficial musculo-aponeurotic system), a fibrous and muscular sheet that envelops the muscles of facial expression and continues into the neck as the platysma muscle;
- gliding spaces, separated by the retaining ligaments (zygomatic, masseteric, mandibular, cervical), which anchor the SMAS and skin to the bone and deep muscles;
- the branches of the facial nerve, the parotid gland and the chewing muscles.
The SMAS was described in 1976 by two French surgeons, Vladimir Mitz and Michel Peyronie [1]. With age, the ligaments slacken and the tissues slide downwards: the cheek drops, jowls appear along the jawline, the nasolabial fold deepens and the neck loses its angle. As long as the ligaments stay attached, they also hold the tissues back during a facelift: this is what separates the two families of technique. Some spaces, such as the premasseter space, are natural cleavage planes beneath the SMAS with no facial nerve branch inside [5].
2. Two families of facelift
The SMAS lifted as a flap, ligaments released: the deep plane
The surgeon works beneath the SMAS, within the gliding spaces, and releases the retaining ligaments of the cheek, jaw and neck one by one. The skin, fat and SMAS stay attached to one another and form a single flap, which can then be repositioned freely upwards and backwards. The pull is placed on the SMAS, not on the skin, which is then redraped without tension.
This family goes by several names for the same principle: SMAS flap, “SMAS lift”, the name long in use, and “deep plane facelift”, the current name. Sam Hamra described it in 1990, extending the early sub-SMAS dissections towards the front of the cheek [2]. SMASectomy, which removes a strip of SMAS after raising it as a flap, and the “high SMAS”, “extended SMAS” and “composite” variants differ in the height and extent of the flap, not in the principle.
The SMAS plicated, ligaments preserved
The surgeon lifts the skin only, then folds the SMAS onto itself with stitches without raising it: this is plication. The ligaments stay in place.
The procedure is shorter and keeps further away from the branches of the facial nerve. But the ligaments, still attached, hold back the front of the cheek: more of the tension falls on the skin, and the effect on the nasolabial fold and cheek is weaker.
The skin-only facelift: a technique to avoid
A subcutaneous facelift lifts the skin alone, then pulls it and removes the excess, without touching the SMAS. It is the oldest technique. Dr Médard de Chardon does not perform it, for three reasons:
- a weak, short-lived result: the skin is elastic and relaxes within a few months, while the deeper tissues have not been lifted at all;
- an unnatural look: all the tension falls on the skin, which gives the “pulled” or “wind-swept” face and sometimes distorts the earlobe;
- poorer-quality scars: under tension, they tend to thicken (hypertrophic scarring) and to widen.
The 2026 review also found a greater aesthetic improvement with the deep plane than with subcutaneous facelifts [7]. “Mini facelifts” offered with short scars are sometimes based on this principle: ask at the consultation what is done to the SMAS.
At Dr Médard de Chardon’s practice, the lower face and neck lift is performed as a deep plane, extended into the neck through the platysma when the neck is lax; neck bands are treated through a short incision under the chin. Plication is used only for some secondary facelifts.
3. Deep plane or plication: the comparison
| Deep plane (SMAS flap, SMAS lift) | SMAS plication | Skin only (subcutaneous) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Work on the SMAS | Lifted as a flap | Folded with stitches, not lifted | None |
| Retaining ligaments | Released | Preserved | Preserved |
| Tissues repositioned | Skin, fat and SMAS as one unit | Skin and SMAS tightened separately | Skin only |
| Tension on the skin | Low: the skin is redraped | Higher | Maximal |
| Jowls, jawline, neck | Marked effect | Good effect on moderate laxity | Weak, temporary |
| Cheek, nasolabial fold | Clear effect | Limited effect | Almost none |
| Appearance | Natural | Natural if laxity is moderate | Often “pulled” |
| Scars | Fine, without tension | Fine | Risk of thickening and widening |
| Permanent facial nerve injury | No more frequent in studies | Reference | — |
| How long the result lasts | 4 to 12 years; superiority not shown | 4 to 12 years | Short |
| At the practice | Technique for the lower face and neck lift | Some secondary facelifts | Not performed |
4. What the studies show
Both families give lasting results and high satisfaction; no study has shown that a deep plane result lasts longer than a plication.
- Complications by technique: a meta-analysis of 183 studies compared each technique with plication. Permanent facial nerve injury did not differ. Temporary weakness was slightly more frequent with high SMAS flaps (1.85%) and composite flaps (1.52%), and major haematoma with the deep plane (1.22%) [4].
- Complications of the deep plane: the largest review, published in 2026 (45 studies, 10,784 patients), reports 6.6% complications overall: temporary facial nerve weakness 1.2%, haematoma 1.8%, seroma 1.7%, hypertrophic scarring 2.8%, infection 0.8%, skin necrosis 0.1%, and no permanent facial nerve injury [7].
- Satisfaction: a 2025 meta-analysis (21 studies, 2,896 patients) found 94.4% of patients satisfied after a deep plane and 87.8% after the facelifts it classes as “SMAS” [6].
- At one year: a 1996 study of 21 patients operated with a different technique on each side (lateral SMASectomy or standard SMAS on one side, extended or composite flap on the other) found no visible difference between the two halves of the face at 6 and 12 months [3]. Ligament release has been considerably refined since then.
These figures come mainly from series published by experienced surgeons, and authors do not all classify techniques in the same way: “SMAS” sometimes means a plication, sometimes a flap. Definitions of complications vary too: the 2025 meta-analysis counts 17.2% complications for the deep plane, against 6.6% in the 2026 review [6, 7]. The level of evidence remains moderate, for lack of recent comparative trials. The result depends above all on the analysis of the face and the skill of the surgeon.
5. Who is it for?
The deep plane suits faces where the cheek has dropped: marked jowls, a blurred jawline, a deep nasolabial fold, a lax neck. Plication, less effective on the cheek, is used at the practice only for some secondary facelifts. A first lower face and neck lift is most often considered from the age of 45. When laxity is just beginning, hyaluronic acid injections or a non-surgical mini facelift may be enough, for a time. A face that has lost volume, particularly after weight loss on treatment, also needs volume: facial fat grafting is often combined with the facelift.
6. Is the recovery different?
Recovery is that of a lower face and neck lift: a 2- to 4-hour procedure under general anaesthesia or local anaesthesia with sedation, at the Clinique Oxford, usually with one night’s stay. A drain is left in place for 24 hours and the dressing is removed on day 2; there are no stitches to remove. Bruising lasts 7 to 21 days and time off 15 to 21 days; gentle exercise resumes from day 15. The result is clear by the second month and lasts 4 to 12 years depending on the quality of the tissues.
7. The risks
The risks are those of any facelift: haematoma, temporary numbness of the cheeks and ears, localised hair loss at the scars, delayed healing made more likely by smoking. Injury to a branch of the facial nerve is exceptional and most often temporary. Choosing a qualified and experienced surgeon reduces these risks, and can remove some of them.
8. The cost
At Dr Médard de Chardon’s practice, the technique does not change the price range: a lower face and neck lift, by deep plane or by plication, costs €5,000 to €15,000 depending on the procedures combined, on quotation after a €100 consultation. It is not covered by the French national health insurance or by top-up insurers.
Dr Victor Médard de Chardon has performed the deep plane facelift since 2009. He trained in deep facelifts under Professor Santini, then refined his technique with renowned surgeons such as Dr Timothy Marten. A plastic surgeon in Cannes since 2011, he has performed more than 1,000 facelifts. He sees patients at his practice at 101 rue d’Antibes from Cannes, Antibes, Nice, Monaco and across the Alpes-Maritimes, as well as from Paris, Marseille, Lyon, Bordeaux and Toulouse, who reach Cannes by train or fly into Nice.
Frequently asked questions
Are a SMAS lift and a deep plane facelift the same thing?
Yes. “SMAS lift” is the old name for the SMAS flap, now called the “deep plane facelift”: in both cases the SMAS is lifted and the retaining ligaments are released. Plication, by contrast, folds the SMAS without lifting it.
Why not have a skin-only facelift?
Because skin that is pulled without lifting the deeper tissues relaxes within a few months. The result is weak, often “pulled”, and the scars, under tension, tend to thicken and widen. Dr Médard de Chardon does not perform this technique.
Does a deep plane facelift give a more natural result?
It lifts the cheek without pulling on the skin, which avoids the “pulled” look. A well-performed plication also gives a natural result on moderate laxity; the difference shows mainly in the cheek and the nasolabial fold.
Does the result last longer than with a plication?
No study has shown this. Both techniques give a result that lasts 4 to 12 years depending on the quality of the tissues; ageing then continues from a rejuvenated face.
Is the deep plane riskier for the facial nerve?
The dissection runs closer to its branches and requires a thorough knowledge of the anatomy. Meta-analyses show no more permanent injuries than with plication; temporary weakness occurs in about 1% of cases and recovers within a few weeks to a few months.
Is a deep plane facelift more expensive?
Not at Dr Médard de Chardon’s practice: a lower face and neck lift costs €5,000 to €15,000 depending on the procedures combined, whatever the technique, on quotation after a €100 consultation.
Does the deep plane treat the neck as well?
Yes. The dissection continues beneath the platysma muscle of the neck and the cervical ligaments are released; neck bands are corrected through a short incision under the chin.
Can a deep plane facelift be done after a previous facelift?
Yes, including after a plication. Tissues that have already been operated on need a careful assessment at the consultation, as the first operation may have altered the dissection planes.
References
- Mitz V, Peyronie M. The superficial musculo-aponeurotic system (SMAS) in the parotid and cheek area. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1976;58(1):80-88. doi:10.1097/00006534-197607000-00013
- Hamra ST. The deep-plane rhytidectomy. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1990;86(1):53-61. PubMed 2359803
- Ivy EJ, Lorenc ZP, Aston SJ. Is there a difference? A prospective study comparing lateral and standard SMAS face lifts with extended SMAS and composite rhytidectomies. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1996;98(7):1135-1143. doi:10.1097/00006534-199612000-00001
- Jacono AA, Alemi AS, Russell JL. A meta-analysis of complication rates among different SMAS facelift techniques. Aesthet Surg J. 2019;39(9):927-942. doi:10.1093/asj/sjz045
- Mendelson BC, Freeman ME, Wu W, Huggins RJ. Surgical anatomy of the lower face: the premasseter space, the jowl, and the labiomandibular fold. Aesthetic Plast Surg. 2008;32(2):185-195. doi:10.1007/s00266-007-9060-3
- Khoury S, et al. The deep plane versus SMAS facelift: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Aesthetic Plast Surg. 2025;49(21):5895-5903. doi:10.1007/s00266-025-05118-x
- Koroma P, et al. Deep plane facelifts: a systematic review and meta-analysis of outcomes. Aesthetic Plast Surg. 2026;50(17):6874-6896. doi:10.1007/s00266-026-06138-x
